Eh! Formaggio 13

This is my wife and I’s favorite pizza place in town. We’ve gone at least once a week for the last 3 years. Thankfully we live 2 miles away.

I haven’t been there since they have changed their menu but, I am sure it is the Eh’s I love. My wife and I drive twenty minutes for this magnificent pie. I recommend “The Greek” for those who stray from the traditional pizza toppings. “The Greek” is loaded spinach, sliced tomatoes, feta cheese, red onions, and black olives. There pizza crust and bread sticks are slathered in a buttery, fresh garlic mixture that is unreal. When they first opened on the west side they made calzones as big as footballs. They have since downsized there calzone portions which are still huge and tasty. For desert you can’t go wrong with New York style cannolis. I also want to mention there caesar salads with their home made dressing. This is the best caesar dressing that I have had in a long time and haven’t found a better one since. I could go on forever but you should sample the menu yourself. You are definitely missing one of Indy’s best by not visiting here.

I really like the pizza. I would not call it cheap at nearly $20 for a large, but it is tasty!! The crust is superb.

My husband and I love this place! Which is saying a lot because he’s a die hard Chicago deep dish style pizza lover.

My husband and I have been to this place many times and its arguably the best pizza in town!
Big portions at very reasonable price.. pizzas also availabe by slices
Recently they have added some interesting appetizers and more choices of sandwhiches.
the Canoli is great too..although they could improve the service a bit.
Must-go kind of a place.

I visited Eh! Formaggio the other night with my daughter and I was very impressed. I ordered a slice of pizza for her and a calzone for me. We both just had water. I was worried that just getting a calzone, I would not get enough to eat. Boy was I wrong! The thing was as large as my daughters head. And her slice of pizza, which they graciously cut up for her, was the size of two slices from any other pizza joint. All of this food only set me back $9. Feeling bloated, but compelled to try a canoli, I dropped another 2.50 for the canoli, which wasn’t as gargantuan as the other dishes, was twice as delicious. It the filling was cold and sorta reminded me of chocolate chip cookie dough. The whole thing was drizzled with chocolate, also. I will be back very soon.

I overnight in NYC several times per month. For those of you who know what real NY Pizza is like….this is it!!

Great pizza, sandwiches, cannoli…oh, and a cute Romainian girl working the counter…very friendly.

Thanks everyone for recommending this place. The lasagne was good and a big serving and good salad. Biggest problem is figuring out what to order. I plan to go back. Want to try the spinkopita.

This is pizza. Period. If you live nearby and eat from chain pizza stores, you are a fool. If you live far away, make a special trip for this pie! The Calzones and anti-pasta salads are just as awesome and the Marinara Sauce will make you take out pad and paper and start a letter home to Mom!

Places like this abound in the Big Apple, but they’re scarce in these parts. Do your taste buds a favor, go out of your way and support a real pizza joint!

My husband is from New Jersey, so he misses real, thin-crust, East-Coast style pizza (the kind you fold to eat). Eh Formaggio satisfies his longings. The calzones are HUGE, and they even have good cannolis, which are really hard to find in Indy!

This place knows their pies people. The owner, from what he said, is from the East Coast, and is one of the founders of the food network. He then had a chain of pizza places, and wanted to retire…? Someone please do an expose’ on this family, and see if I am right, or if they were pulling my leg. It’s hard to tell, because they love to have fun with you at this place.

From the fun menu, to the conversation while you wait for your order, plus, the “Mom” who works the counter makes the desserts and takes care of whatever you need…. they are the best, and the marinara…I would eat is like soup.

Definately the best pizza anywhere…. I wish they were in more locations, or that they delivered.

The best Pizza Cheap

I must admit, it was the name that drew me in to try Eh! Formaggio, but the food was what left an impression. For my …

View the rest of this review